Is it smart to copy a proven app idea and do it better?

By gr0w Research · Updated · From 185 founder interviews · 5 min read

Short answer

Yes, in an analysis of 185 founder interviews, several founders built on a proven product and reached $12K to $440K a month, but each changed something specific: the niche, the country, the core quality or the price. Gravl rebuilt a fitness app with a better workout engine and said it hit $440K a month, while Stoppr's clone of a quit-porn app, aimed at quitting sugar, reached about $12K a month. Founders who copied without a clear difference, or picked a market dominated by big competitors, struggled.

$440K/month
Gravl, which rebuilt Fitbod's idea with a better workout engine (founder's figure)
~2 weeks
time Stoppr, Cal Buddy, Lynx and Youform founders each said they needed to build a first version
$1K → $81K
Cal Buddy's monthly revenue, from month one to about a year later
185
founder interviews analyzed

Does copying a proven app actually work?

It worked for the founders in the library who did it deliberately, and several said outright that originality wasn't the point. Samuel Rondot builds only products that already exist and succeed; across UseArtemis, StoryShort AI and Capacity he reported about $35K a month [1]. Tomer built a Hebrew-language version of the Cal AI idea in about two weeks with Cursor and grew from $1K in month one to $81K a month [2]. Hasam, who built Launchfast, said you don't need a unique idea, just better execution in a proven market [3]. Even Sunflower's founder said on the Superwall podcast that he cloned someone [4]. These are self-reported results from people who succeeded, so the library says little about how many clones failed. One cautionary voice, Boost App Social's founder, urged founders not to simply copycat and to find fresh concepts [5].

What did founders change to differentiate their clone?

Each one changed a single, concrete variable rather than building a vague "better" version.

  • Quality of the core: Julian found Fitbod's workouts poor and built a similar app with a proper workout engine; he also abandoned an earlier plain Hevy/Strong-style tracker because it added no value [6] [6].
  • Niche: David Adius copied Quitter screen by screen, swapped quitting porn for quitting sugar and black for pink [7].
  • Country: Tomer said it doesn't matter that an app exists if no one knows it in your local market [2].
  • Design and simplicity: Charlie Clark built Lynx, a better-looking Linktree alternative, in two weeks [8].
  • Gaps users complain about: Shipper's founders mined competitors' Trustpilot pages, roadmaps and Discord servers; complaints led to mobile app, extension and bot support [9].

Can you undercut a bigger product on price?

Yes, but price alone was rarely enough. Abhishek built Youform after Typeform raised prices, yet he said price can't be the only reason and checked Twitter, Reddit and Typeform's forum for missing features too [10]. He added a generous free tier and reached about $11K MRR [10]. Charlie Clark anchored Lynx's paid plan against Linktree and tried to undercut it; it started around $3 a month and is now about $5 [8]. Julien Nahum priced NoteForms below every Notion form builder because his product had about a tenth of their features [11]. Undercutting works best when paired with a simpler product aimed at users the leader is losing.

How do you pick which app to clone?

Pick one with visible proof of demand, a niche you know, and low maintenance. Samuel's filter: you'd use it yourself, it visibly works, competitors aren't spending thousands on marketing, and it's simple to maintain [1]. He checks competitors' traffic sources in Ahrefs: ads-only growth can be copied in about a week [1]. Stoppr's founder confirmed the target's revenue with an app-intelligence tool like Sensor Tower [7] and checked Google Trends, where "stop sugar" had risen for five years [7]. Tomer added that a small market needs a huge niche, such as fitness and nutrition [2]. Shipper's founders picked a booming category and aimed for 1% of it [9].

How do cloned apps get their first users?

They borrowed the playbook of the original and applied it to an underserved audience. Gravl's Julian posted a technical "how I built it" thread on Reddit, which brought 300,000+ impressions and the first couple thousand users [6]. Stoppr cold-emailed French influencers; first month was about $5,700 [7]. Cal Buddy built ad creatives from viral US app content and ran ads where CPMs are low, then added influencer revenue-share deals that took it from $20K to $80K a month [2]. Shipper ranked for "alternatives to [competitor]" keywords and then grew on X by building in public [9]. Another route is searching Twitter and Reddit for complaints about the leader, as Youform did [10].

What are the risks of cloning?

The main risks are competing head-on with entrenched players, maintenance cost and thin margins. Samuel's first app, UseArtemis, faced Apollo and Lemlist, was hard to maintain and cost about $4K a month to run [1] [1]. Frederick James copied an onboarding breakdown for a habit tracker and got to about $10K a month on paid ads, but warned that ads-only gives a thin margin of about 30% and is hard to sell [12]. Stoppr's margin was about 35% [7]. Clones also get cloned: Sunflower's founder said many competitors were spinning up similar apps [4]. Platform dependence matters too; Andy Klote assessed Airtable's roadmap before building DataFetcher [13].

Founders who built on a proven product, what they changed, and the result (self-reported)
ProductBuilt onWhat changedResult
GravlFitbodBetter workout engine; Spanish ads in South America [6]$440K/month [6]
Cal BuddyCal AIHebrew version for Israel [2]$81K/month [2]
StopprQuitterQuit sugar, pink, France [7]~$12K/month [7]
YouformTypeformCheaper, free tier, import tool [10]$11K MRR [10]
LynxLinktreeBetter design, lower price [8]$31.5K MRR [8]
ShipperLovable, Base44Mobile apps, no jargon [9]$25.6K MRR [9]
StoryShort AIAds-driven faceless video toolBuilt in about a week, ads at once [1]~$20K/month [1]

Frequently asked questions

How fast can you build a clone?

Founders said about two weeks for a first version: Stoppr's clone took 2.5 weeks [7], Cal Buddy two weeks with Cursor [2], Lynx two weeks [8]. Cal Buddy still took about two months to reach the App Store because of Apple approval [2].

Is it enough to just change the color or niche?

It worked for Stoppr, whose clone swapped niche and color and reached about $12K a month, but the new niche was validated first with Google Trends and social posts [7]. Founders with larger results changed something deeper, such as Gravl's workout engine.

Should I clone a market leader or a smaller app?

Several founders cloned leaders but narrowed the target: Shipper aimed for 1% of a booming category [9], and Andy Klote picked niches too small for VC-funded competitors [13]. Samuel's head-on attempt against Apollo was his hardest app to maintain [1].

How can I find complaints about the product I want to beat?

Search Twitter and Reddit for "[tool] alternative" [10], read competitors' reviews and Trustpilot pages and Discord servers [9], or paste app reviews into an AI assistant, as the PEPAI founder suggested [14].

Does copying work for content as well as products?

Clover's Matt said cloning proven formats is about 90% of its campaigns, and the median clone gets about 20% of the original's views, with some doing two to six times better [15].

Sources

Founder interviews on YouTube; numbers are as the founders said them. How this research is done.

  1. [1]I cloned 3 apps and now make $35K/month · UseArtemis, StoryShort AI, Capacity (Starter Story)
  2. [2]I Copied A Huge App. Now I Make $80K/Month · Cal Buddy (Starter Story)
  3. [3]How I built my first SaaS without an audience ($25K/month) · Launchfast (Starter Story)
  4. [4]I speedran an ai app from 0 to $1m/yr in 10 months · Sunflower (Superwall)
  5. [5]Copy This Facebook Ads Strategy, It'll Blow Up Your App · Boost App Social (Superwall)
  6. [6]How I Built It: $400K/Month Mobile App (Gravl) · Gravl (Starter Story)
  7. [7]I vibe coded a $12K/month mobile app (Stoppr Breakdown) · Stoppr (Starter Story)
  8. [8]I quit my job to build this micro-saas. Now it makes $30K/month · Lynx (Starter Story)
  9. [9]I Built A Micro-Version Of A $1B SaaS. Now I Make $50K/Month · Shipper (Starter Story)
  10. [10]I Copied a $100M SaaS, Undercut Their Prices, and Hit $10K/Month · Youform (Starter Story)
  11. [11]How I Built It: $37K/Month Notion App · NoteForms (Starter Story)
  12. [12]I Built a $10K/Month App in 88 Days (Starter Story)
  13. [13]How I Built It: $23K/month micro-saas · DataFetcher (Starter Story)
  14. [14]I Built A $30K/Month in 35 Days · PEPAI (Starter Story)
  15. [15]The NEW App Content Strategy Dominating in 2026 · Clover, Echo (Superwall)