Hard paywall or freemium: which makes more money for apps?

By gr0w Research · Updated · From 185 founder interviews · 5 min read

Short answer

In an analysis of 185 founder interviews, the founders who moved from freemium to a hard paywall reported more revenue: Stronger said about 25%, and App Masters' Steve Young said the trial start rate rose from 6% to 13% with trial-to-paid unchanged. Freemium still won where the product spreads from user to user or where a hard paywall brought bad reviews. These figures are self-reported and come mostly from subscription-app founders.

42 of 185
founder interviews where paywall or pricing was a growth driver
6% to 13%
trial start rate after Steve Young's apps went hard paywall; trial-to-paid stayed flat
~25%
revenue lift Stronger reported from making new users start a trial first
$5K to $8K
monthly revenue SyncToSheets said it reached after removing its free plan

Does a hard paywall make more money than freemium?

In this library, usually yes for mobile subscription apps, though the evidence is founders' own before-and-after reports rather than controlled comparisons. Steve Young, who buys and fixes undermonetized apps, said a hard paywall took the start-trial rate from 6% to 13% while trial-to-paid stayed flat, which doubles revenue on the same downloads [1]. One app he bought went from about $1–2K to $8–10K a month with the same 100–150 downloads a day, after a hard paywall and a $60/year price [1]. Stephen Cravata said a hard, unskippable paywall with a trial pushed Puff Count's conversion to 20–25% and changed the business overnight [2]. Max (Max.ai) used a hard paywall from day one after dropping a plan to sell ad slots [3]. Nicole, behind Glam Up and Sprout, recommended a hard paywall right after onboarding because conversion was better for her [4].

Which founders switched to a hard paywall, and what happened?

Four founders in the library described a switch and its effect. The table below sums them up.

Stronger found out by accident. A toggle bug briefly showed everyone a hard paywall on New Year's Eve, and their phones lit up with purchases. They then made every new user start a Pro trial first, and revenue jumped about 25% overnight with few complaints [5] [5]. Flo of Monai moved from freemium to a hard paywall with a 7-day trial after A/B tests in RevenueCat [6]. He did not give a standalone figure for the switch, because the app's growth also came from a creator partnership.

SyncToSheets, a web add-on, is the non-mobile example. Leandro removed the free plan because free users never needed to upgrade. Users were angry, but revenue went from $5K to $8K a month in about two months [7].

Which founders went the other way, to freemium?

Jack Friks moved his couples app Lovely from a hard paywall to freemium after bad reviews, and because he wanted more friends to use it [8]. He did not report the revenue effect.

Jungle, a study app doing $80–100K MRR, runs freemium. Users see the paywall early in onboarding but can keep using the product, and the team converts them later through retention. The interviewer noted this takes more patience and possibly more capital [9]. About 30–40% of Jungle's new users came from word of mouth [9].

Stagetimer, a web timer with $25K a month, uses a free tier so freelancers bring it to events. Clients see it work, hit a limit at a later event, and pay [10].

When does a hard paywall fit, and when does freemium fit?

A hard paywall fits when you buy traffic or make short-form content that sends cold users, and when the product delivers its value in one session. Freemium fits when users share the product with each other, or when the free user is the acquisition channel.

  • Viral loop: Stronger's founder said a paid app has little K factor, because nobody sends a paid app to friends. Making new users start a trial first cost them that loop, and they decided the trade was worth it [5].
  • Compute cost: YourMove AI keeps a soft paywall for text help but a hard paywall for AI photos, because compute is expensive [11].
  • Long conversion tail: Welltory uses a hardish paywall with no trial that users can close. Over 60% of its conversions came in the months after day one [12].
  • Seat or event-based B2B tools: the Stagetimer pattern above, where the free tier brings in the next paying client [10].

What are the downsides of a hard paywall?

Reviews and reach are the main costs. Friks got bad reviews from a hard paywall [8], and Young said to expect some one-star reviews. He suggested a soft paywall for people who find the app through organic search or a friend, so that hard-paywall traffic comes mainly from paid sources [1]. Stronger's founders said their K factor fell [5].

A hard paywall is also not the whole answer. Vahe Baghdasaryan, a paywall consultant, said the Claim app had a 34% trial start rate, then removed the free trial and earned more revenue [13]. He also said a three-step paywall that mentions the trial several times typically lifts conversion 20–40% over a single screen [13]. Clear 30 raised paywall conversion from 20% to 30% by showing a day-by-day program on the first paywall screen [14].

How should you test it?

Test the structure first and the copy later. Stronger's founders said small copy tests need months of volume to reach significance, so they test how often the paywall appears, how hard it is, and which features it gates [5]. Track trial start rate and trial-to-paid separately, as Young does. The library holds no head-to-head freemium versus hard paywall test on identical traffic, and the founders who report wins are mostly in consumer subscription apps driven by short-form video. If your growth depends on user-to-user sharing, measure that loop before you remove the free tier.

Founders who changed their paywall model and what they reported (self-reported)
Founder / appChangeReported result
Stronger (workout tracker)Freemium to trial-first hard paywallAbout 25% revenue boost overnight, few complaints [5]
Steve Young (App Masters)Added a hard paywall to bought appsTrial start rate 6% to 13%; one app $1–2K to $8–10K a month [1]
Puff CountHard paywall with trialConversion 20–25%, about $40K a month [2]
SyncToSheetsRemoved free plan$5K to $8K a month in about two months [7]
MonaiFreemium to hard paywall with 7-day trialNo standalone figure given [6]
Lovely (Jack Friks)Hard paywall to freemiumFewer bad reviews; revenue effect not given [8]

Frequently asked questions

What is a hard paywall?

It is an unskippable screen, usually after onboarding, that asks for payment or a free-trial start before the user can use any features [2].

Does a hard paywall change trial-to-paid conversion?

Not in Steve Young's case. His start-trial rate rose from 6% to 13% while trial-to-paid stayed flat, so the gain came from more trial starts [1].

Does a hard paywall hurt app reviews?

It can. Jack Friks said his hard paywall drew bad reviews and switched to freemium [8]. Steve Young said to expect some one-star reviews.

Can a free tier still be profitable?

Yes, when the free user spreads the product. Stagetimer, at $25K a month, uses a free tier so freelancers bring it to events where clients later convert [10].

Should every user see the paywall before using the app?

Not always. Welltory's paywall can be closed, and over 60% of its conversions came in the months after day one [12].

Sources

Founder interviews on YouTube; numbers are as the founders said them. How this research is done.

  1. [1]Beginners Guide to Buying & Selling Apps 2026 · App Masters (app acquisitions portfolio) (Superwall)
  2. [2]How I Built It: $40K/Month iPhone App · Puff Count (Starter Story)
  3. [3]I Make $13K/Month From This Simple App · Max.ai (Starter Story)
  4. [4]she makes $400k/mo from ai apps (while in college) · Glam Up, Sprout (formerly Prep AI) (Superwall)
  5. [5]My App Makes $600k/Year Using This Easy Growth Strategy (copy me) · Stronger (Superwall)
  6. [6]How This App Makes $35K/Month · Monai (Starter Story)
  7. [7]How I Built It: $9K/Month Micro-SaaS · SyncToSheets (Starter Story)
  8. [8]He Went From Struggling to Make $1 From His App to Turning Down $1M · Curiosity Quench, PostBridge, Doof, Lovely (Superwall)
  9. [9]this ai study app makes $100k/mo. here's how (no-code) · Jungle (Superwall)
  10. [10]This App Makes $25,000/Month · Stagetimer.io (Starter Story)
  11. [11]he had nothing.. until he built a stupid simple $30k/mo app with AI · YourMove AI (Superwall)
  12. [12]How to Build an $18M/Year Apple Watch App (FREE MASTERCLASS) · Welltory (Superwall)
  13. [13]Our No-Code Apps Made $50M Using THIS Paywall (Superwall)
  14. [14]I Built a $30k/mo App That Helps You Quit Smoking · Clear 30 (Superwall)