Are lifetime deals a good idea for apps and SaaS?
By gr0w Research · Updated · From 185 founder interviews · 5 min read
Short answer
In the founder interviews we analyzed (185 in total), lifetime deals worked best as a limited, early-stage cash raise, not as the permanent pricing model. Flowka's founder said a no-refund lifetime launch made about $117K in 24 hours from 500–600 buyers, and Frill raised about $30K from a private one. The founders who did well then closed the deal and moved to subscriptions. [1] [2]
- $117K in 24 hours
- Flowka's lifetime-deal launch, 500–600 buyers, to an existing email list
- $30K
- Raised by Frill's private lifetime deal, priced at $59–$100
- $20K in 2–3 days
- Subscribr's 50-license lifetime presale, before the product was built
- 97%
- Share of SaveWise revenue from the lifetime plan, as its founder said
Are lifetime deals a good idea for apps and SaaS?
They are a good idea early, with limits, and a weak default for the long run. The founders in the library who used them describe the same logic: you have no data on churn or lifetime value yet, so a lifetime deal gives you cash and committed users without giving up equity. Flowka's Umberto said he didn't regret his and described it as raising capital from customers without giving away equity or board seats [1]. RabbitHoles AI's Praneeth went further: bootstrapped businesses should offer one alongside whatever else they sell, even if it is limited, for the cash, validation and engaged users [3].
The counterpoint is the investor view that you forgo all future revenue from that customer and the business looks less valuable on paper [1]. Founders' answer was to price the deal like a pre-paid 24 months, and to stop selling it. The library is thin on founders who say a lifetime deal hurt them badly, so treat the downside evidence below as limited.
How much cash can a lifetime deal bring in?
From about $20K to about $120K in the cases founders described, depending on audience size and price. Figures are self-reported.
- Flowka: About $117K in 24 hours at pre-launch, from 500–600 buyers on three tiers (about $109, $199 and $349). Umberto had warmed an existing email list for about five weeks first [1].
- Frill: About $30K from a private deal priced at $59–$100, sold through Reddit, Facebook groups, X and lifetime-deal groups [2].
- Subscribr: Gil presold 50 lifetime licenses, raising the price every 10, and made $20K in two to three days before writing the product [4].
- RabbitHoles AI: About $80K in six months after moving to a one-time purchase, starting at $29 for the first 100 users and $49 after [3].
Mike's stated goal for his AppSumo launch was to close the lifetime deal with about $100K in the bank, to fund a year or two of content [2].
What does a lifetime deal cost you in long-term revenue?
It caps what each early buyer is worth, and it can delay recurring revenue. Voicy's founder showed how the two numbers diverge: recurring revenue was about $11K MRR, but cash was $16–20K a month because of lifetime sales. The monthly plan was about $8.49 and the lifetime plan about $260 [5]. Cash was real, but MRR understated it and lifetime buyers would not renew.
Two founders said staying on one-time pricing held them back:
- Cardstock: Kyle sold lifetime access for about $5 and doubted anyone would pay $5 a month. After users pushed him, he switched, and revenue started to grow [6].
- Visualizee: Piotr said one-time payments didn't build recurring revenue and that he should have charged subscriptions from day one [7].
Bulk Mockup's Vikash sold a lifetime deal for a couple of years, partly because he lacked license validation. He later used the funds to hire a developer and move to $15 a month [8].
When have lifetime deals worked best?
They worked in four situations the founders described.
- Pre-launch or validation: Flowka and Subscribr sold before or just as the product existed. Subscribr offered a money-back guarantee until delivery [4].
- Subscription-fatigued buyers: Praneeth's first subscription web app got almost no traction with power AI users who already paid for several models. The one-time desktop version sold [3]. SaveWise's founder said that on the day he launched a subscription, members emailed asking for a lifetime option. The lifetime plan is now about 97% of its revenue [9].
- Downloadable software: Elephas's founder said Mac app customers expect one-time payment, so the company has sold lifetime deals from the start [10].
- No ongoing cost per user: Praneeth used bring-your-own-keys so users pay for the AI, which removed his AI and server costs [3].
A lifetime deal is riskier where each user costs you money every month, because the buyer pays once and keeps using it.
How should you run a lifetime deal?
Keep it short, capped and final. These are the tactics founders described:
- Time and quantity limits: Umberto recommends five to seven days and a fixed number of spots to stop procrastination [1].
- No refunds: He says refunds jeopardize the deal. Buyers who want to try first can wait for subscriptions [1].
- Tiers: Three lifetime tiers let the lower ones anchor the top one and capture skeptics [1]. He also warned that pricing too low out of fear leaves money on the table [1].
- Price ladder: Subscribr raised the price every 10 licenses; RabbitHoles raised it after 100 users [4] [3].
- Use the cash: Mike's sequence is a private deal, then content with the money, then AppSumo, then one last private deal at a slightly higher price, then close it for good [2].
- Use the buyers: Flowka put lifetime buyers in a Telegram group, where they sent detailed feedback [1]. Mike asks them for honest Trustpilot and G2 reviews [2].
| Product | Lifetime deal | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Flowka | $109–$349 tiers, no refunds, limited time | $117K in 24 hours; now subscriptions at $9–10K/month [1] |
| Frill | Private deal, $59–$100 | About $30K raised, then content and AppSumo [2] |
| Subscribr | 50 licenses, price rising every 10 | $20K in 2–3 days before the build [4] |
| RabbitHoles AI | $29, then $49, one-time, bring-your-own-keys | About $80K in six months; moving to recurring [3] |
| Bulk Mockup | Lifetime deal for a couple of years | Funded a developer, then $15/month [8] |
| Voicy | About $260 lifetime vs $8.49/month | $11K MRR but $16–20K monthly cash [5] |
| SaveWise | Lifetime plan alongside subscriptions | About 97% of revenue, about $25K/month [9] |
| Cardstock | About $5 lifetime access | Revenue grew after the switch to $5/month [6] |
Frequently asked questions
Do lifetime deals hurt a company's valuation?
Investors may see lifetime revenue as collected up front, with no future revenue from that customer. Flowka's founder answered that early on you don't know your churn or lifetime value, so pricing a lifetime deal as pre-paid months is reasonable [1].
How should you price a lifetime deal?
Founders priced from about $29 up to $349. Frill used $59–$100, Flowka used about $109, $199 and $349 tiers, and Voicy charged about $260 against $8.49 a month [2] [1] [5]. Flowka's founder said buyers who dislike subscriptions will pay three to five times a yearly plan [1].
Should you sell lifetime deals on AppSumo?
Mike uses it as one step in a sequence, after a private deal and after writing content. He values its large mailing list and aims to close with about $100K [2].
Sources
Founder interviews on YouTube; numbers are as the founders said them. How this research is done.
- [1]My App Made $120K in 24 Hours · Flowka (Starter Story)
- [2]I Built 3 SaaS Apps to $200K MRR: Here's My Exact Playbook · Curator.io, Frill.co, Juno.co, Fluke.co, Smile.co (Starter Story)
- [3]My app failed, then I changed one thing, and made $80K · Canvas Mode (formerly RabbitHoles AI) (Starter Story)
- [4]How I Built It: $30K/month Micro-SaaS (Subscribr Breakdown) · Subscribr (Starter Story)
- [5]I built this app for my dad. Now it makes $18K/month · Voicy (Starter Story)
- [6]How I make $42k/mo passively with simple no-code apps (copy me) · Cardstock, Scanemon (Superwall)
- [7]I was stuck at $100 for 2 years until I made one change. Now my app makes $10K/month · Visualizee (Starter Story)
- [8]How I Built a $12K/Month Micro-SaaS · Bulk Mockup (Starter Story)
- [9]How I Used Reddit To Build a $25K/Month Business · SaveWise (Starter Story)
- [10]How I Built a $13K/Month SaaS · Elephas (Starter Story)