How do you validate an app idea before building it?
By gr0w Research · Updated · From 185 founder interviews · 5 min read
Short answer
Founders in the library validated by putting a fake demo, landing page or post in front of strangers and watching for action, with payment as the strongest signal: Setter AI took a $500 deposit before writing code, and Runafy got 90+ people to pay $5 for an app that didn't exist. In an analysis of 185 founder interviews, 56 of the 161 who said how they started posted content themselves first, which is the cheapest way to test demand. Self-reported numbers; the library has no data on how many ideas failed these tests.
- 56 of 161
- founders who said how they started posted their own content first (analysis of 185 interviews)
- $500
- first deposit Setter AI took before writing any code
- 90+ of 2,000
- waitlist sign-ups who also paid $5 for Runafy before the app existed
- 80K views
- views on PushScroll's fake demo, with about 500 comments asking for the app
Can you validate an app with a fake demo video?
Yes, several founders posted a mock-up or fake demo and built only after people reacted. PushScroll's founders posted a TikTok with borrowed AI push-up-detection footage, ending with a prompt asking whether they should build it; it got about 80K views and roughly 500 comments begging for the app, and they then shipped a 3-screen MVP in two weeks [1] [1]. Lobby's team filmed a PowerPoint-style mock-up, not the real app, to see whether people wanted it; the video reached 7.9 million views [2]. Glow Up's founder said his earlier apps failed because they built without showing users anything; this time content came first and the app followed [3]. The signal in all three: comments asking where to get it, not just views.
A demo can also be a tweet. CodeGuide's founder screen-recorded his workflow, got about 300 sign-ups from it, and linked a landing page [4].
How do you validate with a landing page and waitlist?
Build one page that describes the product, add a single call to action, and count sign-ups. CodeGuide's founder made a landing page in about 30 minutes and collected 1,800 waitlist emails in two weeks before any product existed [4]. Domenico, who flips micro-SaaS tools, validated each idea with a one-page site shared on X and treated a 15% conversion rate as the bar for a good idea [5]. John Rush posts about his own pain point, aims for 100 waitlist sign-ups, then emails them a 90% presale discount and builds only after 5 sales [6].
Setter AI went further: a page with one keyword headline, an ElevenLabs-generated fake demo and a calendar link, put on an already-indexed domain so Google found it within a day [7] [7].
Should you take payment before the product exists?
Payment is the signal most founders trusted most. Setter AI's Joseph said the only real validation is when buyers swipe their card; a $500 Stripe payment before any product existed convinced him [7]. Runafy's Caleb Dean sent Reels traffic to a ChatGPT-built page with a $5 Stripe link: under 50 videos in about two weeks produced 2,000 waitlist sign-ups and 90+ payments, which he called clear validation [8]. Sway's team sold $15 manual dating-profile reviews by DM before the app existed [9].
The same logic works with a service you run by hand. ListKit sold lead lists as a manual productized service before building software [10]. John Rush delivers the solution manually to his first presale customers and iterates before coding [6]. MakeLogo's founder used a Typeform plus payments and fulfilled orders by hand [11].
Is posting the idea on Reddit enough to validate it?
It gives qualitative feedback and a rough count of interested people, but it is a weaker signal than payment. Kyle Fowler posted his card-scanner idea in r/baseball cards and got about 12–15 replies saying they'd use it, which he called decent validation. He later referenced that post in his launch post [12] [12]. He then had 12 paid downloads on launch day [12]. Stagetimer's founder posted a link to a very small niche, and people sent him lists of features they wanted [13]. YadaPhone's Dennis built a prototype in a weekend after Pieter Levels tweeted asking for a Skype alternative, and sales came minutes after his first Reddit post; he said it was "a validated market" rather than an idea [14] [14].
One Starter Story host noted that Reddit's value is the comments from real people, not the traffic or revenue [15].
What signal should you look for?
Look for strangers doing something that costs them effort or money, and set the number before you test.
- Money: a $500 deposit [7], $5 pre-orders from 90+ people [8], or five presales [6].
- Conversion rate: Domenico's 15% on a landing page [5].
- Sign-ups: 1,800 in two weeks [4] or about 100 for John Rush [6].
- Comments asking for access: about 500 on PushScroll's demo [1].
- Existing demand: AI Crea's Pauline showed an MVP to real estate agents who said they wanted to buy and then paid [16].
Weak signals are views alone and friendly replies. Kyle Fowler's early brand-style TikToks drew about 23 likes and didn't convert [12]. The library has no founder data on a standard threshold, so these are individual rules of thumb.
How long should validation take?
Days to a few weeks for most founders here. Runafy's test ran about two weeks [8], CodeGuide's waitlist two weeks [4], and PushScroll shipped its MVP two weeks after the demo went viral [1]. Setter AI's landing page was set up months before the business started, then waited for the first payment [7].
Don't automate before the test passes. Double Speed's founder said to prove the concept before spending time or money on automation [17]; he put a poster on TikTok Shop, got three sales from one AI video, and only then paid a $100 print-shop deposit [17].
| Method | Founder / product | Signal they reported |
|---|---|---|
| Fake demo video | PushScroll | ~80K views, ~500 comments asking for the app [1] |
| Landing page + waitlist | CodeGuide | 1,800 sign-ups in two weeks [4] |
| Fake demo + deposit | Setter AI | $500 Stripe payment before code [7] |
| $5 pre-sale link | Runafy | 2,000 sign-ups, 90+ paid [8] |
| Manual paid service | Sway AI | $15 profile reviews sold by DM [9] |
| Niche subreddit post | Cardstock (Kyle Fowler) | 12–15 replies saying they'd use it [12] |
| MVP shown to buyers | AI Crea | Real estate agents paid immediately [16] |
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest way to test an app idea?
A single landing page or a fake demo video. CodeGuide's founder built a page in about 30 minutes and got 1,800 waitlist emails in two weeks [4].
Do you need an audience to validate an idea?
No. Runafy's founder tested with under 50 videos copying a proven format [8], and Setter AI used a Google-indexed page with no audience [7].
How many pre-sales are enough?
The library gives no standard. John Rush builds after 5 sales [6]; Runafy's founder took 90+ $5 payments as enough [8].
Is a viral video proof the app will make money?
Not by itself. PushScroll counted comments asking for the app, not just views [1], and Cardstock's brand videos got likes but few downloads [12].
What if my idea already has competitors?
That can be a good sign. YadaPhone's founder called his idea a validated market, since people were already looking for a Skype alternative [14].
Sources
Founder interviews on YouTube; numbers are as the founders said them. How this research is done.
- [1]How We Grew Our App to $30K/Month · PushScroll (Starter Story)
- [2]How I Built the #1 App on The App Store (Twice) · Lobby, Bro (Superwall)
- [3]My mobile app made $800K in 365 days · Glow Up (Starter Story)
- [4]From Zero to $42K/Month in 90 Days with AI · CodeGuide (Starter Story)
- [5]I made $1M flipping apps · Softgen.ai, Pitch Deck Generator, OneTap.ai, YourCoverLetter.com, Recoupledgpt.com, Tweetsbot.io, AIWebDesigner.io (Starter Story)
- [6]I Make $250K/Month From 20 Apps · Unicorn Platform, SEO Bot, Listing Bot (Starter Story)
- [7]How We Built a $10K/mo SaaS · Setter AI (Starter Story)
- [8]I speedran an ai app from 0 to $100k exit in 26 days · Runafy (Superwall)
- [9]I speedran a new app from 0 to $2m/year in 6 months (here's how) · Sway AI, Cal AI (Superwall)
- [10]I Built A $1M SaaS In 87 Days · ListKit (Starter Story)
- [11]I Locked Myself In A Room, Made 17 Apps, & Sold 2 for $265,000 · MakeLogo.ai, TalkNotes (Starter Story)
- [12]How I make $42k/mo passively with simple no-code apps (copy me) · Cardstock, Scanemon (Superwall)
- [13]This App Makes $25,000/Month · Stagetimer.io (Starter Story)
- [14]I rebuilt a $1B app and now make $14K/month · YadaPhone (Starter Story)
- [15]How I Built a $13K/Month SaaS · Elephas (Starter Story)
- [16]How I Built It: $10K/Month AI Image Generator · AI Crea, Next.js Directory (Starter Story)
- [17]How to Make Viral Content 100% Using AI in 2025 · Double Speed (Superwall)